Pittsboro Toys just expanded, and they are well worth the extra space.
This toy shop specializes in organic, eco-friendly, and handmade toys. That being said, this isn't a tiny little shop. You can get pretty much any toy you want here (they are a slew of Melissa & Doug, Gund, PlanToys, and LEGO options, too).
When we were in they were still unpacking inventory, and there was already a lot in here. Prices were reasonable. Not discount, but not over the moon either. C had a great time as they have not 1, not 2, but 3 activity & train tables up front for play.
The hardest thing about this shop is the parking. We went during a weekday and getting a spot was fine, but Hillsboro (15/501) gets pretty busy so getting out was a very exciting experience. Just drive safe.
There are many other things in Pittsboro that are worth a visit, so include this toy shop in your next excursion!
44 Hillsboro Street